Above $1 Million Carlisle PA Real Estate, Homes, Condos for Sale

$2,200,000

This property is being sold as a package with Sheds, Weeklys and Efficiencies, as part of an Estate. Property is being Sold AS IS. Please see associated documents for financial package. Any additional questions should be put in writing in email to Listing agent Sia. There will be 3 showing times ONLY: Aug 1st 10 am - 2 pm. Aug 4th 4-7pm. Aug 9th 2-4 pm. All Offers will be due Aug 12th by 5pm and please give attorney till Aug 17th for response.

1502 Holly Pike, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Alpha State Realty. Contact: (717) 243-5400

$2,000,000

This property is 90% leased. Investment opportunity. Property includes Address 461 E North Street vacant lot, which consists of .94 Acres. Taxes are estimated.

469 E North St, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Alpha State Realty. Contact: (717) 243-5400

$1,200,000

Fully Rented, Turn-Key 4-Unit Townhome Building!

10-16 Morgan Circle, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of New Home Star Pennsylvania LLC. Contact: (678) 516-4222

$2,000,000

**BUSINESS IS NOT CLOSING** PRICE INCLUDES REAL ESTATE, BUSINESS VALUE, & EQUIPMENT *** Established in 1978, Wenger Meats & Ice has built a longstanding reputation as one of Carlisle's premier food service providers and wholesale food manufacturers. The business offers a diverse range of products and services, including fresh retail meats, catering, wild game processing, deli products, and prepared hot foods. Generating more than $1.6 million in gross sales during 2025, this offering presents a turnkey opportunity to acquire a successful, established operation. The sale includes the commercial real estate, business enterprise value (going concern), and all associated furniture, fixtures, and equipment FF&E, allowing a purchaser to seamlessly continue operations from day one. This is a locally well-known commercial property offering approximately 10,224 square feet of building area on 0.9882 acres in a highly visible location along East Louther Street in Carlisle Borough. Originally constructed circa 1945 with a retail addition completed in 1997, the masonry and block building is well suited for a variety of retail, food processing, distribution, warehouse, or commercial service uses. The building features approximately 2,300 square feet of retail space, a commercial-grade kitchen, customer restroom, preparation room, employee restroom, multiple refrigerated storage areas, walk-in cooler/freezers, warehouse space, and a second-floor manager's office. The improvement offers a functional layout for a wide range of owner-user oinvestment opportunities. The 0.9882-acre parcel is triangular in shape with direct access from East Louther Street and is served by all public utilities, including water, sewer, and natural gas. The property is zoned C5 Entranceway Commercial, allowing for a broad range of commercial uses. Located on the east side of Carlisle Borough, the property benefits from proximity to the U.S. Army War College and adjoins the former Frog Switch & Manufacturing Company site, which is slated for redevelopment. This strategic location provides excellent potential for future growth and redevelopment within one of Carlisle's established commercial corridors.

511 E Louther St, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Wolfe & Company REALTORS. Contact: 7172431551

$1,800,000

10,000+ square foot building currently leased to County Assistance Office. Building will be available for occupancy by end of this year (2026). A total of 57 parking spaces with lot across the street included as part of the entire property. C-2 zoning offers numerous permitted uses to accommodate your need. See associated documents for additional information to answer most of your questions. Limited hours and days for showings given current status of tenant. Owner would consider long-term lease as well. Initial lease rate would be $14/square foot NNN.

33 Westminster Dr, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Shearer 24, LLC. Contact:

$2,600,000

Opportunity Zone Mixed Use Development Opportunity. This infill redevelopment opportunity in one of Carlisle’s most connected locations is comprised of two parcels totaling 5.34 acres. Located within an Opportunity Zone and featuring flexible UM – Urban Mixed Use zoning that supports a wide range of permitted uses. Concept plans show potential for 100+ apartments plus mix of commercial uses. Includes an existing 40,000+ SF industrial building, creating added potential for adaptive reuse. Ideally located adjacent to the Carlisle School District complex, less than two blocks from Dickinson College, and within walking distance to Downtown Carlisle’s shops and restaurants, the property benefits from strong local demand drivers and exceptional neighborhood connectivity.

321 Cherry St, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams of Central PA. Contact: 7177614300

$1,200,000

A great opportunity to acquire over 34 acres of flat, productive farmland in one of Central Pennsylvania's most sought-after growth corridors. Situated in Carlisle, Cumberland County, this expansive parcel offers an excellent opportunity for future residential development. The property is adjacent to Mayapple Golf Club and the successful residential neighborhood, Mayapple Village. Carlisle's strategic position along the I-81 and PA Turnpike corridors provides residents effortless connectivity to Harrisburg, Shippensburg, and the broader mid Atlantic region. The area's strong school district, established retail and dining, and continued population growth make it a compelling market for new residential supply. Whether you're a regional builder, national developer, long-term land investor, or farmer this property delivers the location, scale, and site characteristics to make your next project a success. Reach out today for more information!

York Rd, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of RSR, REALTORS, LLC. Contact: (717) 763-1212

$1,149,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Luxury Custom Home in South Middleton School District Experience exceptional craftsmanship and elevated living in this stunning custom-built Musser Home Builders home offering 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, and 2,763 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. This home seamlessly blends luxury finishes, energy-efficient construction, and timeless architectural details. From the moment you arrive, you’ll appreciate the home’s striking curb appeal featuring a beautiful combination of brick, cedar, and vinyl siding, a welcoming covered front porch, insulated garage doors, and a premium architectural roof with standing seam metal accents. Step inside to discover soaring 15 ½ foot vaulted ceilings with exposed rafters, rich engineered hardwood flooring, custom millwork, and an abundance of natural light throughout. The heart of the home showcases custom cabinetry, granite countertops, premium GE appliances, a built-in coffee bar, and stunning craftsmanship around every corner. The spacious great room features a dramatic double-sided brick fireplace that extends to the covered rear porch, creating the perfect space for both everyday living and entertaining. The luxurious first-floor primary suite offers a 13 foot vaulted ceiling, custom walk-in closet, and a spa-inspired bathroom with a curb-less tile shower. Additional highlights include custom tile work, solid-core interior doors, crown molding, built-in features, upgraded plumbing fixtures, and granite and quartz countertops & extensive closet organization systems throughout. Built with quality and efficiency in mind, the home features Weather Shield Signature Series windows, Therma-Tru exterior doors, superior insulation, a two-zone natural gas HVAC system, whole-house humidifier, ERV system, electronic air filtration, and energy performance that exceeds building code standards. Enjoy peaceful evenings on the covered rear porch complete with a brick fireplace and beautiful mountain views. This is a rare opportunity to own a meticulously crafted custom home where luxury, comfort, and quality construction come together in one exceptional package. A home of this caliber is more than just a place to live—it’s a lifestyle.

1006 Stonehill Ln, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of 1972 Realty. Contact: 7175613800

$1,975,000

Located on Holly Pike, this property is an easy 15 minute drive from major retailers and PA Turnpike. This site is located on a heavily traveled road and offers excellent visibility with 2 entrance and exits onto Holly Pike. A premier commercial opportunity on a generous 13 acre lot. This versatile property features an expansive 11,000+ square foot main building, formerly the home of the Carlisle Country Market and also a leased single family home on the back of the property

1446 Holly Pike, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Commerical Industrial Realty Co, Inc.. Contact: 7177615070

$2,000,000

Positioned in the heart of Downtown Carlisle’s vibrant Central Business District and Historic District, this exceptional mixed-use property offers a rare opportunity to reimagine a landmark asset. Encompassing approximately 34,329 square feet on 0.61 acres, this former bank building consists of a striking two- and three-story masonry building originally constructed in 1863, rich with historic character and architectural presence. Ideally located adjacent to the county courthouse complex and just steps from the town square, the property benefits from strong pedestrian traffic along West High Street—one of Carlisle’s most active corridors connecting the square to Dickinson College. The surrounding area is anchored by a dynamic mix of local retailers, institutional uses, restaurants, and businesses, creating an energetic and highly desirable downtown environment. The building’s main level is currently configured with bank branch space and administrative offices, while the upper floors feature a combination of office suites and former apartment units ready for revitalization. Throughout the property, classic architectural elements shine, including beautiful masonry detailing, expansive arched windows that flood the interiors with natural light, and consistently high 10.5-foot ceilings that enhance the sense of space and openness. Well-suited for a transformative redevelopment, the property offers significant upside potential. The ground floor lends itself to a variety of commercial uses such as retail, restaurant, or office space, while the upper levels present an ideal canvas for the creation of spacious, luxury apartment units—capitalizing on the building’s historic charm, ceiling heights, and oversized windows. Additional features include a full basement with multiple interior and exterior access points, five roofing systems in adequate condition, various fire escapes, and 16 off-street parking spaces located at the rear of the property, easily accessible via side and rear alleyways. This is a compelling opportunity to invest in and revitalize a prominent downtown asset in one of Central Pennsylvania’s most sought-after communities.

1 W High St, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Wolfe & Company REALTORS. Contact: 7172431551

$1,100,000

Welcome to 298 McAllister Church Rd, Carlisle—a truly unique mixed-use residential property offering a multitude of possibilities and exceptional income potential. Currently operating as a thriving party venue and live entertainment hotspot, the property serves wine and beer through a leased license, creating an inviting and established destination for events and gatherings. The property features a fully renovated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom main home with an attached 2-car garage (set up to also have an in-home business), along with a separate 1-bedroom apartment—ideal for additional rental income, guest accommodations, or owner occupancy. Also included on site is a flower shop (leased space), four additional garages, and a beautifully updated greenhouse complete with new patio doors and electric insulated power curtains. Square footage is estimated between house and greenhouses. Extensive improvements have been made during current ownership, including a complete remodel of the main house with a new roof, updated mechanical systems, and modern cosmetic finishes throughout. The outdoor spaces have been transformed with pergolas and a concrete entertainment area, while the wine shop and greenhouse have been fully upgraded to support the current business operations. At the list price, all furniture is included, along with all equipment in the wine store—making this a true turnkey opportunity. Buyers should note that in order to continue wine and beer sales, a liquor license must be obtained through lease or purchase. A private public sewer connection is also available. Whether you're an investor, entrepreneur, or someone seeking a live/work lifestyle, this property delivers unmatched flexibility, charm, and opportunity.

298 Mcallister Church Rd, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty. Contact: (800) 383-3535

$1,899,900

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Exceptional equestrian property set on approximately 50 acres with two pole buildings. Thoughtfully designed with purpose and functionality in mind, this property features numerous custom finishes throughout. Building One: 40x84 with two stories, including a 1,800 sq ft barndominium with a covered porch facing west—perfect for relaxing while watching the sun set over the pastures. The living area features 2 large bedrooms, 2 full baths, and one half bath, enhanced by luxury finishes such as vaulted ceilings, a custom kitchen with granite countertops, and LVP flooring. The second story also includes a loft for additional hay storage. The ground floor barn area offers a 12-foot-wide aisleway, 6 stalls (5 with attached daylight runs), heated tack and utility rooms, a wash stall, and a sawdust bay. Also attached is an 18x70 garage addition with overhead doors at each end. Building Two: 72x200 featuring a 72x120 indoor riding arena with sand footing over stone dust, a viewing area, 8 stalls (6 with attached daylight runs), a 14-foot aisleway, tack room, wash stall, hay storage above the stall area, and additional space for equipment storage. Outdoors there is a 110x170 outdoor arena with sand footing and premium quality lighting. Fenced pastures include two 5+/- acre pastures and two one-acre pastures, all with run-in sheds. On the west end of the property, a tree-lined area borders the Yellow Breeches Creek, while the remaining acreage has been used for hay production. Professional photos and additional details will be added soon. Experience the perfect blend of comfort and equestrian lifestyle—schedule your private tour today and see all this incredible property has to offer!

67 E Yellowbreeches Rd, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams of Central PA. Contact: 7177614300

$1,899,900

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Exceptional equestrian property set on approximately 50 acres with two pole buildings. Thoughtfully designed with purpose and functionality in mind, this property features numerous custom finishes throughout. Building One: 40x84 with two stories, including a 1,800 sq ft barndominium with a covered porch facing west—perfect for relaxing while watching the sun set over the pastures. The living area features 2 large bedrooms, 2 full baths, and one half bath, enhanced by luxury finishes such as vaulted ceilings, a custom kitchen with granite countertops, and LVP flooring. The second story also includes a loft for additional hay storage. The ground floor barn area offers a 12-foot-wide aisleway, 6 stalls (5 with attached daylight runs), heated tack and utility rooms, a wash stall, and a sawdust bay. Also attached is an 18x70 garage addition with overhead doors at each end. Building Two: 72x200 featuring a 72x120 indoor riding arena with sand footing over stone dust, a viewing area, 8 stalls (6 with attached daylight runs), a 14-foot aisleway, tack room, wash stall, hay storage above the stall area, and additional space for equipment storage. Outdoors there is a 110x170 outdoor arena with sand footing and premium quality lighting. Fenced pastures include two 5+/- acre pastures and two one-acre pastures, all with run-in sheds. On the west end of the property, a tree-lined area borders the Yellow Breeches Creek, while the remaining acreage has been used for hay production. Experience the perfect blend of comfort and equestrian lifestyle—schedule your private tour today and see all this incredible property has to offer!

67 E Yellowbreeches Rd, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams of Central PA. Contact: 7177614300

$1,100,000

Owner is ready to retire and let the next owner thrive in this amazing commercial location! Roof is 5 years old. 2 parcels being sold together. Neighboring parcel known as 1048 Harrisburg Pike is zoned Commercial/Residential, has sewer line and boasts a 30'X50' pole barn. Just shy of 1 acre for both lots together.

1050 Harrisburg Pike, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Realty Agency, Inc.. Contact: 7173003942

$2,495,000

Turn-key Diner Opportunity! Prime commercial property located at Exit 52A off US 81 in Carlisle, PA. This fully equipped restaurant sits on 2.45 acres with Commercial Highway zoning, offering excellent visibility and access at a major interchange. Features include high traffic count of 18,000 cars per day, ample parking, and a building in very good condition. Ideal for continued restaurant use or repurposing for retail or other commercial ventures. Excellent investment in a growing commercial corridor!

1400 Harrisburg Pike, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Sites Realty, Inc.. Contact: 7173344674

$1,100,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Discover the potential of this unique 29.47-acre farmette featuring a classic brick Cape Cod home nestled in the scenic countryside of Silver Spring Township in Cumberland Valley School District. Offering 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, this home is full of character and ready for your personal touch. With a bit of TLC, it could be transformed into a stunning private estate. Enjoy additional living space with a walk-out lower level that includes a finished game room, plus a cozy sunroom at the back of the home—perfect for relaxing while taking in peaceful views of your land. A rare bonus: the home is equipped with natural gas heat, uncommon for properties of this size. The property is enrolled in Clean & Green, keeping your real estate taxes low, and is zoned Rural Residential, offering flexible use and plenty of possibilities. A large detached pole barn provides ample space for equipment, storage, or hobby use. Currently, a local farmer rents and farms the land, creating a low-maintenance income opportunity. With its generous acreage, existing infrastructure, and idyllic setting, this property is ideal for someone looking to create a private retreat, hobby farm, or investment property. So much potential—don’t miss this chance to make it your own!

1370 W Trindle Rd, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX 1st Advantage. Contact: (717) 591-5555

$3,500,000

5.73 acres at signalized intersection zoned C-2 (Commercial General) & R-H (Residential High Density). 2.3 & 1.2 acre tracts can also be available for land lease for $9750 & 5100/month NNN. High traffic volume. 1310 & 1312 Holly Pike and 20 Marsh Drive are the properties included. See associated docs for additional info.

1310-1312 Holly Pike, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Shearer 24, LLC. Contact:

Browse All Carlisle PA Above $1M Properties for Sale

Above $1 Million Carlisle Real Estate