Fayetteville PA Historical Real Estate, Homes for Sale

Cute as a button! This solid all-brick rancher offers three bedrooms and 1.5 baths and has been well cared for throughout. The attached carport can also double as a covered patio—the choice is yours! Out front, retractable awnings add both charm and shade. Step inside to find a well-appointed living room that flows into the dining area and spacious kitchen. Down the hall, you’ll find three bedrooms, with the primary bedroom featuring its own attached half bath. Downstairs offers plenty of space for all your storage needs, along with a nicely finished portion that makes a great den or additional living area. Don’t miss your chance to grab ahold of this solid, well-maintained home and make it your own!

213 Joyce Dr, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Samson Properties. Contact: 7033788810

$175,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Front house has 3-bedrooms, one bath and rear apartment has 2-bedrooms, one bath. Electric is metered separately. Has termite damage in front house and currently no stairs to the basement. Large lot.

94 W Main St, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX 1st Advantage. Contact: (717) 591-5555

$270,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

**Be prepared to fall in love.** This beautifully updated home offers nearly 1,500 square feet of timeless charm, thoughtfully renovated between 2018–2019 while preserving the character that makes it special. The inviting kitchen and dining area flow seamlessly together, featuring crisp white cabinetry, granite countertops and stainless steel appliances, with plenty of room to create your own custom island. Updated bathrooms, an exceptionally spacious primary bedroom, original built-in shelving in the living room and convenient first-floor laundry option add both style and functionality. The enclosed rear porch offers a versatile mudroom and storage space, while the generous deck, fire pit area and spacious, level partially fenced yard create an ideal setting for outdoor entertaining and everyday enjoyment. Even the two-car garage offers added versatility, with the rear space ready to serve as a workshop, hobby area or additional storage. Beautifully updated, thoughtfully designed and filled with possibilities, this is a home you’ll want to experience in person.

110 Lincoln Dr, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty. Contact: (800) 383-3535

$150,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

396 Westview Rd, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Wolfe & Company REALTORS. Contact: 7172431551

$48,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Discover a serene retreat nestled in the coveted Mountain Creek Cabins Recreational / Residential Campground, where relaxation meets nature. This stunning cabin-style residence, fully renovated in 2023, boasts modern appliances, including a gas oven/range and large double door freezer / refrigerator, ensuring culinary excellence. Enjoy the tranquility of your surroundings with picturesque views of the lush trees and the gentle flow of Conococheague Creek, creating a perfect backdrop for relaxation. The property features a charming rear yard, ideal for outdoor gatherings or quiet moments. With parking on a crushed stone driveway, convenience is at your fingertips. This exclusive lifestyle offers a unique blend of rustic charm and contemporary comfort, making it a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle. Embrace the opportunity to own a piece of paradise where every day feels like a vacation. Experience the ultimate in relaxation and calm living, surrounded by nature's beauty. Don't miss your chance to make this dream home yours! Near Caledonia State Park with front stocked trout stream, fish in the rear lake. Bass, Crappie, Pike. deer, turkey in state park. PLEASE NOTE: Cash ONLY - Cabin on rented land - $470 a month land rent. In Flood Zone - Flood insurance not required since no financing permitted.

198 Black Gap Rd Unit #34, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty. Contact: (800) 383-3535

$239,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Welcome to 75 Ritchey Road in Fayetteville! This beautifully refreshed home is move-in ready with updates throughout. Enjoy fresh paint, new flooring, and a restored hardwood floor in the living room that adds warmth and character. The updated kitchen features new cabinets, countertops, and appliances, while the newly renovated bathroom offers a fresh, modern feel. Outside, you'll find a fenced yard with plenty of space to enjoy, along with a detached garage providing additional parking, storage, or workspace. There is also a new roof and new windows! With so many updates already completed, all that's left to do is move in and make it your own!

75 Ritchey Road, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Charles & Associates RE. Contact: (717) 299-2100

$269,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

***OFFER DEADLINE: Sunday, August 30th at 5:00 PM. Please submit your clients’ highest and best offer by the deadline for seller consideration. Seller reserves the right to accept an offer prior to the deadline.*** Welcome to 115 Wagner Road, a one-of-a-kind property offering an incredible combination of space, privacy, and peaceful wooded surroundings. Tucked away among the trees, this expansive 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers approximately 3,100 square feet and delivers the secluded, cabin-like atmosphere you’ve been looking for—all while still providing plenty of room to spread out and make it your own. The home’s spacious interior offers generously sized living areas and a warm, inviting feel that complements its beautiful natural setting. Recent improvements include a new roof in 2022, a brand-new garage door, fresh interior paint, and new flooring in the back bedroom and basement bathroom. The mostly finished basement provides yet another area for versatile living space, with plenty of flexibility for a recreation room, home office, gym, hobby space, or additional entertaining area. A large finished room at the rear of the home adds even more usable space and possibilities to fit your needs. Outside is where this property truly sets itself apart. Surrounded by mature trees and natural beauty, the setting provides a sense of privacy and tranquility that’s increasingly hard to find. Whether you’re enjoying a quiet morning, entertaining family and friends, or simply unwinding at the end of the day, the wooded surroundings create the feeling of your own private retreat. With over 3,100 square feet of space, a serene wooded setting, flexible living areas, and numerous recent improvements, 115 Wagner Road offers tremendous potential for its next owner. Come experience the space, character, and peaceful setting this unique Fayetteville property has to offer.

115 Wagner Rd, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Taylor Properties. Contact:

$259,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Move right into this fully furnished beautifully curated home! Most of the furniture is included with the sale, a unique opportunity! Extensive updates and improvements have been made to the property during the last two years of ownership. The list of improvements will be shown in the photos. This is a two bedroom, two full bathroom house with lots of room to spread out. Large rooms with four exterior doors and quick access to the beautiful semi-private property! Residents of Greenwood Hills have access to the community pool and other recreational facilities. Lawn tractor and lawn mower also convey!

28 Pine Way, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Flat Fee Realty. Contact: 7173775651

$225,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

In the heart of Fayetteville, Pennsylvania, you will find 108 W. Main Street. Blending timeless character with everyday comfort, this unique property offers generous living space, thoughtful details, and a convenient location. With more than 1,800 square feet, the home features spacious rooms, high ceilings, and a functional layout that feels open and inviting. Original hardwood floors, detailed woodwork, and classic built-ins highlight the craftsmanship and historic appeal found throughout the property. The kitchen provides ample cabinet space and functionality, while the bathrooms retain classic features that complement the home’s distinctive style. Offering 3 bedrooms and flexible living areas, the floor plan can easily accommodate a home office, family room, guest room, or additional recreational space. Outside, the large private backyard offers plenty of room for gardening, entertaining, relaxing, or creating a play area. Off-street parking and a well-maintained front porch add to the home’s convenience and welcoming curb appeal. Located near local shops, restaurants, and community amenities, the property also provides convenient access to Route 30 and Interstate 81. If you appreciate historic charm, spacious rooms, and the relaxed atmosphere of small-town living, 108 W. Main Street is an opportunity worth exploring. Schedule your private showing and discover everything this Fayetteville home has to offer.

108 W W Main Street, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of EXP Realty, LLC. Contact: 8883977352

$227,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Charming & Priced Just Right! Nestled just outside of beautiful Caledonia State Park, this cute-as-a-button 3-bedroom, 1-full-bath home is the perfect blend of charm, functionality, and value. Beautiful hardwood floors run throughout the main living areas, including the welcoming living room, kitchen, and dining room. And storage? You’ll have plenty! Closets, pantries, and custom closet storage systems make it easy to keep everything organized. The full basement provides tons of potential for future expansion, recreation space, hobbies, or additional storage, complete with a convenient covered exterior entrance. Outside, enjoy the patio and backyard, plus a detached garage/workshop ready for your vehicles, equipment, or projects. A metal roof and central air add to the appeal. With its fantastic location near Caledonia State Park, you can enjoy hiking, swimming and lots of outdoor time! With a price that makes homeownership attainable, this is one you won’t want to miss!

7944 Lincoln Way E, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Realty Agency, Inc.. Contact: (717) 267-0011

$69,900

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

*NEW PRICE!* Escape to your own private retreat in the heart of Michaux State Forest! This quaint and secluded cabin at 776 Perry Dr offers the perfect getaway surrounded by thousands of acres of beautiful state forest. Whether you're looking for a peaceful weekend escape, hunting camp, or home base for outdoor adventures, this property puts nature right outside your door. The current owner has enjoyed hunting just yards from the cabin for many years, with an abundance of wildlife making this area a true outdoor enthusiast's paradise. Spend your days hiking, hunting, exploring the forest, or simply relaxing and enjoying the peace and privacy of your surroundings. The screened-in porch will quickly become your favorite spot for morning coffee, playing cards with friends, or simply taking in the sounds of nature. When you're ready for a little entertainment, you're just minutes from Totem Pole Playhouse, Caledonia Golf Course, swimming, and countless recreational opportunities, including Laurel Lake, Fuller Lake, Long Pine and more. Enjoy the beauty, tranquility, and adventure that Michaux State Forest has to offer while still being within 30 minutes of historic Gettysburg and just 10-15 minutes from Walmart, shopping, restaurants, and other everyday conveniences. Meticulously maintained by the current owner including a new metal roof in 2021 & fully insulated in 2023. Secluded yet convenient, this location truly CANNOT BE BEAT! **This is a land lease and cannot be a primary residence. Buyer must be a PA resident, and this is a cash only sale*

776 Perry Dr, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Realty Agency, Inc.. Contact: (717) 267-0011

$299,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Welcome home to this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath raised ranch, built in 1970 & situated on a half acre lot. As you walk through the door you will be greeted with natural sunlight which leads into the kitchen. The dine-in kitchen is perfect for everyday meals or entertaining. Off the kitchen to the right you will find a spacious primary bedroom that boasts a beautiful brick fireplace that creates a warm & cozy focal point for a relaxing getaway after a long day. The primary bedroom offers ample closet space & a special touch with French doors that lead directly to a private back patio & bringing in plenty of natural light. From the left of the kitchen you will find two additional bedrooms with ample closet space & a full bathroom. The full basement offers additional space for storage or future expansion. The home also features a 1-car attached garage. With easy access to Route 30, it makes travel to Chambersburg, Gettysburg, Hanover or York convenient & quick. With a perfect blend of modern comforts & natural scenery this property is ready for you to walk through the door & make it yours! Don’t miss your chance to own this beautiful home in a prime location—call me to schedule your tour today!

7009 Chambersburg Rd, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty. Contact: (800) 383-3535

$22,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

2 bedroom,1 full bathroom cabin near Caledonia State Park. Fish from your back door! $375/Month Land Lease.

198 Black Gap Road Unit #55, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Howard Hanna Company-Camp Hill. Contact: 7179209600

$249,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Investment Opportunity or Perfect Place to Call Home! Welcome to 380 Mont Alto Road, Fayetteville! This spacious two-story home offers 3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, and is connected to public water and public sewer. Situated on a nice-sized lot, this property provides plenty of outdoor space for gardening, entertaining, or simply enjoying the outdoors. Currently tenant-occupied, this home presents an excellent opportunity for investors seeking an income-producing rental property. Looking for a place to call your own? This home also has the potential to become a wonderful primary residence. Conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, schools, and major commuter routes, you'll enjoy the perfect balance of small-town living with easy access to everyday conveniences. Whether you're expanding your investment portfolio or searching for your next home, 380 Mont Alto Road is a property worth seeing. Schedule your private tour today!

380 Mont Alto Road, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty. Contact:

$215,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

A Mountain Retreat with a View - and a Lifestyle All its Own! Escape the ordinary and discover the charm of cabin living in the heart of Michaux State Forest. Overlooking Caledonia Golf Course, this 4-bedroom, 2-bath cabin offers a peaceful setting surrounded by nature, while still putting some of the area's favorite attractions right outside your door. The cabin is part of a recreational land-lease community where ownership is designed around enjoying your own private getaway. Although you will be comfortable here in any season, the property is intended for recreational use. Therefore, the cabin cannot be used as a primary residence or offered as a rental on a regular basis. The sale is cash-only and the lease transfer is subject to approval and available to Pennsylvania residents. Step inside and you'll immediately appreciate the character and warmth that make a cabin feel like a cabin. Four bedrooms provide plenty of space for family and guests, while two full bathrooms and comfortable gathering areas make it easy to settle in and stay awhile. The centerpiece of the living space is a wood-burning floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace. Whether you're returning from a day outdoors or simply enjoying a quiet evening in, it's the perfect backdrop for cozy nights and time spent together. The screened-in front porch adds another amazing dimension to the cabin. With views toward the golf course and the surrounding natural beauty, it's an inviting spot for morning coffee, afternoon relaxation, dinner with friends, or evenings spent enjoying the peaceful surroundings. Many of the furnishings convey with the sale, allowing you to spend less time worrying about what to bring and more time enjoying the cabin! Beyond the property, you'll have quick access to some of the best recreational and entertainment opportunities in the area. Totem Pole Playhouse is nearby for seasonal live performances while Caledonia State Park offers hiking, fishing, swimming, picnicking, and plenty of ways to enjoy the outdoors. If you've been looking for a place where weekends feel longer, gatherings feel more memorable, and getting away from it all is actually possible, this cabin deserves a look. It's not simply a place to stay - it's a place to make your own traditions.

9856 Golf Course Road, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Iron Valley Real Estate of Central PA. Contact: (717) 344-5950

$235,000

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

247 West Main St has been refreshed and is looking for a new owner! 4 Beds and 1 Full bath with a large 2 car detached garage! New paint and flooring throughout! Kitchen has been renovated with granite countertops. New plumbing and brand new heat pump! Exterior has new vinyl siding as well! Many new windows and a new flat roof in the rear portion of the property! Seller will provide a 1 year warranty!

247 West Main St, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Cedar Spring Realty. Contact:

$375,000

Extraordinary opportunity for an up-and-coming restauranteur! Sale includes restaurant equipment and the Real Estate. This restaurant is turn-key and let's go. Sparkling clean equipment, kitchen, hood system, pizza oven, and dining room. Walk-in freezer and refrigerators with surge protectors, and self-close doors. Separate dish room, separate office, and open design bar area where customers can see the Chef in action. Restaurant has ample parking, great visibility, easy access, and bright signage. Also note the property sits on 4.15 wooded acres that backs up to State Game Land. 2nd floor includes a storage room and a nearly complete 1 bedroom apartment for additional income. Unique and entrepreneur ready.

6418 Chambersburg Rd, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Sites Realty, Inc.. Contact: 7173344674

$575,000

Mim's - A Fayetteville Institution for almost 50 Year is now available for purchase. The owner is retiring and wants this saucerful business to go on. The fully equipped running restaurant along with the attached home a large salt water swimming pool and the detached garage all located on 1.58 acres on West Main Street in Fayetteville. Owner willing to make Mim's a new family business for someone in the Fayetteville Community.

423 W Main Street, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Samson Properties. Contact: 7033788810

$475,000

LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION, 1.5 ACRES HIGHWAY ROAD FRONTAGE UNLIMITED POSSIBILITIES This is all the buildings on the south side of route 30 from the large building to the corner of Dymond Ave including the BBQ shop and the rental sheds Would make a good drive thru coffee shop or similar. ! Large building with a few smaller buildings. Highway location. With a large lot and commercial zoning this could be used for many things. Two story building is for retail. As are all other buildings. Would be a great place for a strip Mall, Convenience store/gas, restaurant, office space, the sheds are in good shape and mostly rented for additional income

3650 Lincoln Way East, Fayetteville

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty. Contact:

Browse All Fayetteville PA Historical Properties for Sale

Fayetteville Historical Real Estate